{martindwyer.com}
 
WORDS | All Archives |

Lost in Translation Thirty Six

April 22, 2009
11:37 AM

Those of my friends who know me as a word nerd will not be surprised to find that I came across something interesting while perusing the dictionary this morning with my breakfast coffee.
In my Collins Robert my eye was caught by the word butter, immediatly followed by the expression; He looked as if butter wouldn’t melt in his mouth
I was immediatly intrigued to discover the translation;
On lui donnerait le bon Dieu sans confession
On first glance I translated this as; He could go to confession to God
which I thought was highly subtle.
Then I looked at it again and realised that it must mean ; He could be sent to God without confession which seems to me to be different from the English original which implies, I think, that even though he looks innocent he may well not be.

Comments

  1. martine joulia

    on April 22, 2009

    On lui donnerait le Bon Dieu sans confession… yes, but who knows if he deserves it ?
    In Spanish they say :
    Parecía no haber roto un plato en su vida, i.e. : he looked as if he never broke a plate in his all life.

  2. Peter Denman

    on April 22, 2009

    My translation: “You would give him God [i.e. the host, communion] without [requiring him to go to] confession”. H’mm?

  3. Martin

    on April 22, 2009

    Aha !

  4. padraic

    on April 22, 2009

    I thought I might find a different idiomatic phrase i nGaeilge but all I found in de B was “Shílfeá nach leáfadh an t-im ina béal” – the only difference is that the pretender of innocence is female.

The comments are closed.


| All Archives |
  Martin Dwyer
Consultant Chef